The Ultimate Homeowner Insurance Renewal Checklist
📋Maximize your coverage, unlock missing discounts, and protect your home.
Let’s be honest: given the choice, most people would rather do almost anything else than review their property insurance. According to a recent industry report conducted by Léger for Allstate Canada, clients would literally rather clean their gutters or organize their junk drawers than sit down to audit their policy details. It’s understandable; insurance manuals aren’t exactly thrilling beach reads.
Many homeowners tend to overlook the importance of regularly reviewing their home insurance policies, which can leave them vulnerable to unexpected financial hardships.
Table of Contents
Policyholder Discount Criteria
⚠️
Conditional Discount Alert: While most discounts often apply automatically, specific conditional discounts require verified, up-to-date homeowner parameters. If your policy file lacks correct, updated documentation, these savings cannot always be grandfathered or activated.
📱Note for mobile users: Scroll left or swipe across the table below to view all columns and information.
| Company | Policyholder Age | Claims-Free | Loyalty | Mortgage Free | Credit Score і |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sandbox Mutual | 50+ years of age | Available after 3 years | Applied at Renewal | Available | Consent required |
| My Mutual | 10% (50+), 15% (60+) | Available after 3 years | Added after 10+ yrs | Available | N/A |
| Peace Hills | 5–15% (Age 40+) | Available after 3 years | Applied at Renewal | Available | Consent required |
| SGI Canada | Applied Immediately | Available after 3 years | Applied at Renewal | Available | Consent required |
| Red River | 10% (50–59), 15% (60+) | Available after 3 years | Applied at Renewal | Available | Consent required |
| Wawanesa | Applied Immediately | Available after 3 yrs or first-time home buyer | Applied at Renewal | Available | Consent required |
💡
Securing Your Mortgage-Free Status: Paid off your home loan? To activate a mortgage-free discount, insurers cannot simply take your word for it. The financial institution must be legally deleted from the policy text, which requires submitting an official “Release of Interest” or mortgage discharge document issued by your lender.
| Company | Security & Alarm | Property & New Home | Other Discounts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sandbox Mutual | 24-hr Central Burglar Alarm | – | 5% New Business |
| My Mutual | 24-hr Central Burglar Alarm | 20% New Home (<5 yrs) | 5% First Time Home Buyers |
| Peace Hills | 10% (Burglar/Fire); 15% (Both) | New Home (1-15%); Resistant Roof (5%) | Non-smoker discount ended in 2026 |
| SGI Canada | 24-hr Central Burglar Alarm | – | Backwater valve |
| Red River | 15% Central; 5% Local | New Home (up to 20%) | 10% First Time Policyholder |
| Wawanesa | 24-hr Burglar + Fire Alarm | Age of home, roof, heating, plumbing | New Business; Water leak detection |
*Disclaimer: These are not a complete list of all available insurance discounts or providers. It provides an overview of the most common discounts offered by these insurance companies.
Deductible Management
Choosing the right deductible is a practical way to manage your insurance costs. A deductible is the amount you agree to pay out of your own pocket when you make a claim. By agreeing to take on a larger share of the cost in the event of a loss, you can often lower your annual premium.
Below is an overview of how increasing your deductible can impact your base premium:
| Deductible Amount | Average Premium Discount |
|---|---|
| $1,000 | 10% |
| $2,500 | 20% |
| $5,000 | 25% |
| $10,000+ | 35% |
*Disclaimer: These figures are estimates based on an average of available market data. Actual savings will vary by company and your specific policy details.
Scheduled High-Value Items
Sometimes, the base deductible on your home insurance policy might not be the best fit for every single item you own. For scheduled items, you can often set a different deductible to help make the coverage more affordable.
For instance, when you schedule expensive jewelry, you can choose a higher deductible specifically for that item. This lowers the premium for that specific coverage. If you schedule a ring worth $15,000 and select a $2,500 deductible, you receive a 10% discount on that jewelry’s premium on a Wawanesa policy.
Individual Coverage Deductibles
You can also apply this strategy to listed coverages on your policy, like weather-related risks. Wawanesa policies have a specific deductible for hail and windstorm damage.
If your policy has a minimum deductible of $2,500 for these events, you might choose to increase that to $5,000 or $10,000. In exchange, your insurer applies a discounted rating factor to your premium, which lowers your overall cost.
Understanding Sewer Back-up
What is Sewer Back-up?
Sewer back-up occurs when water or sewage suddenly escapes or backs up into your home through a sewer, septic system, sump, or drain. This typically happens during heavy rainfall or blockages in municipal lines, causing water to pool inside your residence or your detached private structures.
Sewer back-up occurs when water or sewage suddenly escapes or backs up into your home through a sewer, septic system, sump, or drain. This typically happens during heavy rainfall or blockages in municipal lines, causing water to pool inside your residence or your detached private structures.
It is a separate coverage from your base policy and is intended for cleanup and repair following these specific, often costly, plumbing-related events.
Common Sewer Back-up Scenarios
Scenario 1: Municipal Main Blockage
During a period of heavy rain, the municipal sewer line becomes overwhelmed. Waste is pushed back through the sewer pipe and exits through the basement floor drain, causing significant water damage to your finished basement flooring and personal belongings. This is a type of sudden and accidental failure.
Scenario 2: Sump Pump Failure
Your sump pump, which is designed to keep water away from your foundation, experiences a mechanical failure during a storm. Because the pump is no longer operating, water accumulates in the sump pit and eventually overflows into the basement. This is a type of sudden and accidental failure.
Property Status Rules
It is essential that the occupancy status listed on your insurance policy accurately reflects how the property is being used. Insurance coverage (and cost) is predicated on this status; if your occupancy has changed but your policy has not been updated, your coverage may not be effective during a claim.
🏚️
The Vacant Property Rule
A property is deemed vacant when all occupants have completely moved out with absolutely no intention of returning, regardless of remaining furniture. If a home sits vacant for more than 30 consecutive days, standard homeowner package protections cease. You must secure a formal Vacancy Permit to maintain core fire coverage.
🏢
The Rented Property Rule
This applies when the primary owner no longer lives at the location, and the home is turned over to a tenant under a lease or rental agreement. Transitioning a home into a rental space requires cancelling your homeowner policy and converting it to a dedicated Rental Property Package to protect both the structure and your landlord liability.
Commercial Business Exposure
Sub-Limits on Commercial Property: A standard homeowner policy can impose strict caps or even exclude coverage for business property.
The table below outlines how some insurer property packages restrict business tools compared to available enhancements:
| Business Property Category | Average Sub-Limits | Special Limits Enhancement |
|---|---|---|
| Business Tools, Books & Office Furniture | $5,000 maximum combined limit. | Increased to $7,500 combined limit. |
| Business Computer Hardware & Software | $5,000 maximum combined limit. | Increased to $10,000 combined limit. |
*Disclaimer: These summaries are for general guidance only. Available limits change frequently and vary significantly between insurance companies.
When Commercial General Liability Extensions Are Required:
Standard home personal liability does not cover business pursuits. You will need a dedicated Home Business Extension Endorsement or separate commercial policy if your work involves:
- Clients Visiting the Premises: If patrons visit your home for services, any slip-and-fall incidents on your property line require specialized commercial liability extensions.
- Commercial Courier Deliveries: Frequent business inventory shipments arriving at a residential address significantly elevate your hazard exposure.
- Home Daycares: Operating a daycare requires submitting a specialized Daycare Questionnaire. Some insurers charge a flat premium per child, capped at 6 children (excluding your own). Note: If your property features a trampoline or swimming pool, daycare liability extensions are strictly ineligible.
*Disclaimer: This is not an exhaustive list of business exposures that may apply to your premises. If you are not sure whether you need additional coverage, you should discuss it with your advisor.
Renewal Planning
🚨
The 30-Day Window: If you want your broker to check and cross-compare prices across alternative Saskatchewan insurance carriers (remarketing), the earliest this can be executed is 30 days prior to your renewal date. Contact your broker 45 days early to set an appointment so everything is prepared to run the moment the 30-day window opens.
🏗️
Reconstruction Costs & Renovations
Ongoing building material and labour spikes mean old property valuation profiles may leave you severely underinsured. You can request that your broker run an updated Home Evaluation Estimator to verify that your home meets the accurate limits required to safeguard your Guaranteed Replacement Cost (GRC) protections.
Important: Failure to notify your insurer of major renovations may result in those improvements not being covered in the event of a loss, even if you have GRC coverage. Requirements vary among insurers; when in doubt, always inform your broker.
✈️
Unoccupied Travel Check-In Mandates
Planning an extended trip? The single most important action to ensure your home insurance pays out is to comply with the terms related to your home being unoccupied. Insurers may require the property to be monitored to prevent small issues (like a burst pipe) from becoming catastrophic losses.
Note: Insurer requirements vary. Check out our list to see if your requirements include, for example, having the water supply shut off and drained, or having a competent individual check the home daily. Always leave the heat on during the winter season.
Important Notice: The scenarios provided above are for illustrative purposes only. In the event of any discrepancy between this article and your insurance policy, the actual policy wording and documentation prevail. Always refer to your specific contract for precise coverage details, including conditions, definitions, and exclusions that apply to your individual insurance.
Ready to review your policy? 🛡️
Don’t wait until your renewal date has already passed, as many structural changes cannot be applied retrospectively. Take proactive control today!
Stay Connected With Harvard Western
Thanks for reading our article; I hope you found this guide to reviewing your home insurance policy helpful. Here are some more ways to access more insurance information and tips:
1.
Visit our Blog/article page each month, where we publish various insurance articles and share information on specific industry products.
2.
Learn more about Home Insurance or get a quote, and visit our product page for comprehensive information.
3.
Follow us on LinkedIn to stay up to date on the latest insurance articles and company updates.
Last updated:
Posted in Home & Tenant on December 1, 2023 by Harvard Western Insurance
Share: Tweet
